Murderers VS Sheriffs Tier List (2026) — Best Weapons Ranked

Murderers VS Sheriffs Duels has one of the most active trading communities on Roblox. The first team to win 5 rounds takes the match, and while every weapon skin is purely cosmetic with zero impact on gameplay stats, the rarest skins carry serious trade value. Knowing which items sit at the top of the market matters if you're trading up or building a collection.

We've ranked every notable weapon skin in MVSD from S Tier to C Tier as of March 2026. These rankings are based on current trade value, market demand, rarity tier, and how consistently each item holds its worth over time. Whether you're a veteran trader or just getting started, this list will help you understand what's worth chasing.

S Tier — Best Weapons in Murderers VS Sheriffs

S Tier items are the crown jewels of MVSD trading. These are the weapons that command the highest prices, generate the most trade offers, and consistently hold or increase in value. If you own any of these, you're sitting on a small fortune in the trading market.

Dragonfire Bundle Set

The Dragonfire Bundle Set is the single most valuable item in all of Murderers VS Sheriffs Duels right now. At roughly 600K trade value, it towers above everything else in the game. The set includes matching knife and gun skins wrapped in dragon flame effects that look genuinely impressive during gameplay.

What makes this set so dominant is scarcity. The Dragonfire Bundle has been removed from the store rotation entirely, which means the only way to get it now is through player-to-player trades. Supply keeps dropping as accounts go inactive, and demand hasn't slowed down. In our experience tracking MVSD trades over the past several months, the Dragonfire Bundle has only gone up in value.

Frostbite Gun

Frostbite Gun holds the title of most valuable single gun skin in MVSD at approximately 180K trade value. Its ice crystal design stands out immediately in any lobby, and it's become the centerpiece of most high-level trades. When someone offers a Frostbite Gun, people pay attention.

Demand for this gun remains consistently high across the trading community. It's one of those items where finding a seller is the hard part, not finding a buyer. If you're working your way up through mid-tier trades, the Frostbite Gun is a realistic end goal that still carries major prestige.

Willow Case Bundle

The Willow Case Bundle rounds out S Tier with a 200K trade value that reflects its extreme rarity. Like the Dragonfire Bundle, it was pulled from the store and has only become harder to find since then. Collectors treat it as a must-have, and the demand is through the roof.

We've seen this bundle hold its value more steadily than almost any other item in the game. It doesn't fluctuate with seasonal trends the way some limited items do. That stability makes it both a strong trading asset and a solid long-term hold for anyone who manages to acquire one.

A Tier — Excellent Weapons

A Tier weapons are the bread and butter of serious MVSD traders. They're valuable enough to anchor major trades but accessible enough that you can realistically work toward owning them. These items carry strong demand and don't lose value quickly.

Ice Pegasus Knife

The Ice Pegasus Knife is a Legendary tier knife featuring a stunning winged ice design that catches the eye in any lobby. It sits at around 120K trade value and enjoys strong, consistent demand in the trade market. The fantasy-inspired aesthetic makes it one of the most visually appealing knives in the entire game.

This knife trades well both as a standalone piece and as part of larger package deals. We've tracked it holding relatively stable in value over the past few months, which makes it a reliable asset for traders looking to store value without worrying about sudden drops.

Celestial Gun

Celestial Gun is a Legendary weapon with cosmic particle effects that make it one of the flashiest guns in MVSD. At roughly 100K trade value, it's a premium item that pairs perfectly with its matching knife. The galaxy-themed visual effects are subtle enough to look clean but distinct enough to stand out.

Guns typically command higher trade values than knives in MVSD, and the Celestial Gun follows that pattern. It's worth about 5K more than its matching Celestial Knife, which sits at 95K trade value. Owning the full set bumps the combined value slightly above what you'd expect from adding the individual pieces together, since set completeness carries its own premium.

Celestial Knife

The Celestial Knife completes the cosmic duo at 95K trade value. Its galaxy-themed blade design features swirling particle effects that mirror the gun's aesthetic. While it sits just below the Celestial Gun in value, it's still a highly sought-after piece that trades frequently in the mid-to-high tier market.

If you already own one half of the Celestial set, prioritizing the other half is a smart move. Complete sets are always easier to trade upward, and the Celestial pairing is one of the most recognized in the game.

Fang Set

The Fang Set includes a matching knife and gun with a sharp crimson design that looks aggressive without being over the top. At roughly 80K combined trade value, it's the entry point to A Tier and a solid stepping stone toward the higher-value items on this list.

Demand for the Fang Set has stayed consistent throughout early 2026. It's one of those items that always seems to have interested buyers, which makes it easy to move when you need to restructure your inventory for a bigger trade.

B Tier — Good Weapons

B Tier items won't turn heads in the same way S or A Tier pieces will, but they're genuinely useful trading tools. These weapons have solid visual designs, reliable demand, and enough value to serve as building blocks for traders working their way up the ranks.

Mermaid Set

The Mermaid Set is an Ultra Rare tier bundle that includes a knife and gun with ocean-themed teal effects. At approximately 50K combined trade value, it's one of the more valuable B Tier items and trades regularly in mid-level trading circles.

The aquatic design has a niche but loyal fanbase. It doesn't appeal to everyone, but the players who want it tend to want it badly. That concentrated demand keeps the value propped up even when the broader market softens. We've found the Mermaid Set to be a reliable item to hold between larger trades.

Strife Set

The Strife Set features a dark purple energy design across both its knife and gun skins. Sitting at about 45K combined trade value, it's just behind the Mermaid Set and offers a similar trading experience. The moody aesthetic appeals to players who prefer darker-themed cosmetics.

In terms of trade frequency, the Strife Set moves at a steady pace. It's not the fastest item to sell, but it also doesn't sit in your inventory for weeks waiting for a buyer. That middle-ground reliability is exactly what makes B Tier items useful for active traders.

Reaper Knife

Reaper Knife is an Ultra Rare scythe-style blade that carries roughly 35K trade value. It's particularly popular during Halloween-adjacent trading periods, when demand for spooky-themed items spikes across the MVSD community.

Outside of seasonal peaks, the Reaper Knife still holds respectable value. Its unique silhouette makes it instantly recognizable, and that visual distinctiveness translates into steady interest from collectors who want variety in their inventories.

Reef Gun

The Reef Gun rounds out B Tier with a coral reef design and an Ultra Rare classification. At around 30K trade value, it's the most affordable item in this tier but still a meaningful piece for anyone building a diverse trading portfolio.

Demand for the Reef Gun is steady without being spectacular. It won't be the item that makes or breaks a major trade, but it's a reliable add-on piece that can bridge value gaps when you're negotiating. Think of it as a useful tool in your trading toolbox rather than a destination item.

C Tier — Average Weapons

C Tier is where most players begin their MVSD trading journey. These items won't impress veteran traders, but they serve an important role as accessible entry points into the market. If you're new to trading in Murderers VS Sheriffs, this is your starting line.

Ginger Set

The Ginger Set is an Ultra Rare bundle sitting at about 15K combined trade value. What makes it stand out in C Tier is its best-in-class value-to-demand ratio. More people want this set relative to its price than almost any other item in the game at this level.

For new traders, the Ginger Set is our top recommendation as a first serious trading piece. It's affordable enough to acquire through basic gameplay and trading, but popular enough that you won't struggle to find someone willing to deal. It's the perfect launchpad for working your way up to B Tier and beyond.

Hologram Set

The Hologram Set offers another solid Ultra Rare option at approximately 12K combined trade value. Its futuristic visual style appeals to a different crowd than the Ginger Set, giving new traders multiple entry points depending on what deals they can find.

We've tested both sets as starter trading pieces, and the Hologram Set trades nearly as quickly as the Ginger Set. The 3K value gap between them is small enough that either one works as your foundation. Pick whichever you can acquire first and start building from there.

Standard Rare Knives and Guns

Standard Rare weapons with cyan background rarity fall in the 1K to 5K value range. They're the most common tradeable items in MVSD and carry a low trade ceiling. You won't build wealth from these alone, but they function as small change in the trading economy.

These items are most useful as sweeteners in larger trades. When you're 2K short of matching someone's asking price, tossing in a Standard Rare can close the gap. Don't stockpile them with the expectation of value growth, though. Their supply is too high for that to work out.

Tier List Summary Table

Here's the full breakdown of every weapon ranked in this tier list, with current trade values as of March 2026. Use this table as a quick reference when you're evaluating trade offers or deciding what to target next.

How We Ranked These Weapons

Ranking weapon skins in MVSD isn't like ranking characters in a fighting game. Since every skin is cosmetic only and doesn't affect gameplay performance, our tier list is based entirely on trading metrics. Here's what we looked at.

Trade value is the primary factor. We tracked average sale prices across major MVSD trading communities and Discord servers over the past two months to establish current market rates. Items with consistently higher trade values earned higher tier placements.

Market demand is the second pillar. An item can have a high listed value, but if nobody actually wants to buy it at that price, the number is meaningless. We factored in how quickly items move in trades and how many active buy offers exist at any given time. The Dragonfire Bundle, for example, has buyers lined up at all times despite its massive price tag.

Rarity tier plays a supporting role. Items classified as Legendary by the game's own system tend to hold value better than Ultra Rares, and Ultra Rares outperform standard Rares. This aligns with supply dynamics — fewer copies of higher-rarity items exist in the ecosystem.

Value stability is the final consideration. Some items spike and crash with seasonal events or content creator hype. We favored items that maintain their value over weeks and months rather than items that are temporarily inflated. A weapon that holds 100K steadily is more useful to a trader than one that swings between 60K and 140K unpredictably.

It's worth repeating that none of these rankings reflect gameplay power. A player with default skins has the exact same combat capabilities as someone wielding a full Dragonfire set. The tiers here are strictly about collectibility and trade market positioning.

For more on this game, check out our MVSD codes list for free rewards, or visit the free Robux guide for Murderers VS Sheriffs to earn while you play.

Frequently Asked Questions