Outcome Memories vs Forsaken (2026) — Which Roblox Survival Horror?
Outcome Memories and Forsaken are two of Roblox's standout asymmetric survival horror games, where one powerful hunter chases a team of survivors trying to escape. They share that core DNA, but they feel very different in practice. Outcome Memories is a Sonic.EXE-flavored indie project built around chaotic large lobbies and a giant green ring escape, while Forsaken is a more polished, ability-rich competitive game with an all-star roster of Roblox community characters and one of the biggest communities in the genre. This comparison breaks down their concept, match format, characters, progression, and player counts — and gives an honest recommendation for July 2026.
In This Comparison
At a Glance
Both games are free to play and both are asymmetric horror at heart, but they sit at different ends of the scale-and-polish spectrum. Here is how the two stack up on the attributes that matter most before you pick one.
| Attribute | Outcome Memories | Forsaken |
|---|---|---|
| Genre | Asymmetric survival horror (Sonic.EXE-inspired) | Asymmetric survival horror (all-star Roblox roster) |
| Match format | Up to 21 survivors vs 1 executioner | Small survivor team vs 1 Killer |
| Roster / characters | Classic Sonic characters (Amy, Tails, etc.); executioners are corrupted versions | All-star roster of Roblox community characters as Survivors and Killers |
| Progression / cosmetics | Earn Rings for skins & emotes (cosmetic only) | Deep character unlocks & cosmetics, ability-driven |
| Player count | ~7,876 concurrent, 314M+ visits | Very high concurrent, hundreds of millions of visits |
| Best for | Sonic.EXE fans wanting chaotic large-lobby escapes | Players wanting polished, competitive, ability-rich horror |
Concept & Theme
Outcome Memories is a community, fan-made indie horror project heavily inspired by the Sonic.EXE: The Disaster series. It runs on place ID 14608970270 under the current title "Outcome Memories v0.2," and it leans hard into creepypasta roots: classic Sonic-franchise heroes are the survivors, and the hunter is a twisted, corrupted version of those same characters. The whole thing plays out in a purgatory-like realm, and because the game is still an early v0.2 build, it has that raw, evolving indie feel — fast, tense, and unpolished in the way early passion projects often are.
Forsaken takes a different route to a similar feeling. It is a more polished, higher-production asymmetric horror game built around an all-star roster of Roblox community characters — recognizable faces from across the platform — who appear as both Survivors and Killers. The theme is less about one franchise's mythology and more about a celebration of Roblox horror culture as a whole, with a cleaner presentation and a heavier focus on distinct, ability-driven characters. If Outcome Memories is a love letter to Sonic.EXE, Forsaken is a love letter to the wider Roblox horror community.
That difference in theme shapes who each game appeals to. Fans of Sonic and the Sonic.EXE genre will feel immediately at home in Outcome Memories, where the entire cast and tone are pulled from that world. Players who want a broader, more polished horror experience — and who enjoy seeing a curated cast of Roblox characters with their own quirks — will find Forsaken the more complete package.
Match Format & Objectives
The clearest gameplay split between the two is lobby size. Outcome Memories runs large lobbies: up to 21 survivors face a single executioner, for a full server of 22 players. That scale makes every round chaotic and team-heavy — you are rarely the only target, and survival is often about staying with the pack rather than winning a one-on-one. The survivor objective is simple and dramatic: stay alive until the timer hits roughly 1:20, when a giant green ring opens on the map, then run through it to escape. The executioner is racing to wipe the lobby before that ring appears, so the final seconds before 1:20 are the tensest stretch of the match.
Forsaken uses a tighter, more focused asymmetric format built around a smaller survivor team facing one Killer. Instead of a large-scale scramble, rounds revolve around completing objectives — generator-style tasks that survivors work through to open their route to escape — while a single Killer hunts them down. That smaller, objective-driven structure makes matches feel more deliberate and competitive: positioning, timing, and reading the Killer matter more than sheer numbers, and every survivor pulls real weight because there are fewer of them.
Both games boil down to "escape before the hunter gets you," but the texture is different. Outcome Memories is a large, hectic sprint toward a single dramatic exit, where crowd dynamics and the shared 1:20 countdown drive the round. Forsaken is a smaller, methodical objective race, where completing tasks under pressure is the path out. If you like big, unpredictable lobbies, Outcome Memories delivers that; if you prefer a controlled, skill-tested match, Forsaken's format is built for it.
Characters & Roles
Outcome Memories builds its roster from classic Sonic-franchise characters, and each one is a distinct role rather than a skin. Amy is a melee and ranged stunner who uses her hammer to stay close and defend teammates, buying cornered survivors the split second they need to escape. Tails is a ranged support who assists from a distance and can fly teammates away from danger — a clutch tool for pulling someone out of a losing chase. The executioner side is made up of corrupted versions of those same characters, so learning a survivor's kit also teaches you what its twisted counterpart can do. It is a focused, franchise-tied cast where team composition — some defenders, some support — is what keeps a lobby alive.
Forsaken's roster is generally deeper and more ability-driven. Its all-star cast of Roblox community characters appear as both Survivors and Killers, and each brings its own unique abilities and cosmetics to the table. The design leans into character identity: picking a character is picking a distinct playstyle with its own tools, counters, and skill ceiling, on both the survivor and the killer side. That depth is a big part of why Forsaken plays as a competitive game — mastering a character's kit and matchups is a meaningful part of getting good.
So the character comparison mirrors the games' broader personalities. Outcome Memories offers a tight, thematically consistent Sonic cast where roles are clear and the fun is in coordinating a big team. Forsaken offers a wider, ability-rich roster where individual character mastery carries more weight. Neither is strictly better — it depends on whether you want a cohesive franchise cast or a deep, varied lineup to grind through.
Progression & Cosmetics
In Outcome Memories, progression runs on Rings and other currency you earn by playing matches. You spend what you bank to unlock skins, emotes, and other cosmetics for your characters. Crucially, these are visual only — a skin never changes a character's abilities or stats — so a brand-new player and a veteran with a full collection start every round on equal footing. Because the game is still an early v0.2 build, store contents and any game passes shift between updates and tend to stay minimal and cosmetic, so it is best to check the in-game store for what is currently offered rather than trusting stale figures.
Forsaken's progression is broader and tied more closely to its characters. Alongside cosmetics, there are character unlocks and a deeper meta-progression that reflects the game's larger, more competitive scope — the roster itself is part of what you work toward, and cosmetics let you personalize the characters you main. The result is a progression system with more to chase over the long term, which suits players who want a game they can sink dozens of hours into rather than dip in and out of.
Both games keep the important stuff fair: the paid and earned extras are cosmetic-leaning, and you do not need to spend to reach the escape objective in either. The difference is depth. Outcome Memories keeps progression light and cosmetic, matching its quick-round indie identity, while Forsaken offers a fuller sense of long-term growth through its characters and unlocks.
Community & Player Counts
By raw scale, Forsaken is the bigger game. It is one of the more popular asymmetric horror titles on Roblox, with a very high concurrent player count and hundreds of millions of visits, backed by a large, active community. That size feeds back into the experience: quick queues, a steady stream of opponents at all skill levels, and the kind of ongoing support and meta discussion that a big competitive community generates. If you want a game that will reliably have a full, lively lobby whenever you log on, Forsaken has the numbers.
Outcome Memories is a genuine indie success on its own terms. As of July 2026 it holds around 7,876 concurrent players, has crossed 314 million visits, and sits at roughly 478,000 favorites. Those are strong figures for a project still labelled v0.2, and they reflect a dedicated Sonic.EXE-fan audience rather than a mass-market crowd. It sits well below Forsaken's overall scale, but it comfortably fills its large 22-player lobbies and has a passionate community around it.
The practical takeaway: both games are alive and populated, so you will get matches in either. Forsaken simply offers more of everything — more players, more content cadence, and a bigger competitive scene — while Outcome Memories offers a tighter, more niche community bonded over the Sonic.EXE style. Neither is a ghost town, so your choice comes down to the kind of experience you want, not whether the game is populated.
The Verdict
There is no single winner here — the right pick depends on what you want out of an asymmetric horror game. Choose Outcome Memories if you are a Sonic.EXE fan who wants chaotic, large-lobby survival: 21-survivor rounds, a dramatic green-ring escape at 1:20, and a Sonic-franchise cast, all in a fast, raw indie package that is easy to jump into casually. Choose Forsaken if you want a polished, ability-rich asymmetric horror game with the biggest community: a deep all-star roster, objective-driven matches, more long-term progression, and a large competitive scene with instant queues. In short, Outcome Memories wins on chaotic social fun and Sonic.EXE flavor; Forsaken wins on polish, depth, and scale. Both are free, so trying each yourself is the surest way to know which fits.
Earn Free Robux for Either Game
Want Robux for cosmetics, passes, or avatar items in Outcome Memories, Forsaken, or any other Roblox game? Earnaldo lets you earn free Robux by completing simple tasks — no surveys spam, no downloads, just real rewards.
Frequently Asked Questions
Both are asymmetric survival horror games where one hunter chases many survivors, but they differ in scale and polish. Outcome Memories is a Sonic.EXE-flavored indie project with large lobbies of up to 21 survivors versus 1 executioner, all played as classic Sonic characters, where survivors escape through a giant green ring at around 1:20. Forsaken is a more polished, competitive game with an all-star roster of Roblox community characters, deep unique abilities, and a much larger active community, where survivors complete objectives to escape a single Killer.
Forsaken is the larger game by a wide margin, with a very high concurrent player count and hundreds of millions of visits, making it one of the more popular asymmetric horror titles on Roblox. Outcome Memories is a strong indie success in its own right — around 7,876 concurrent players and 314 million-plus visits as of July 2026 — but it sits well below Forsaken's overall scale.
Outcome Memories runs large lobbies of up to 21 survivors against a single executioner, for 22 players in a full round, which makes matches chaotic and team-heavy. Forsaken uses a tighter asymmetric format built around a small survivor team facing one Killer, which keeps rounds more focused and competitive rather than large-scale.
Outcome Memories can feel more forgiving for casual players because the huge survivor team means you are rarely the only target and survival often comes down to sticking with the group until the green ring opens. Forsaken has a steeper learning curve because each character has deep, distinct abilities you need to learn, but it rewards that effort with more competitive, skill-driven matches.
Yes. Outcome Memories draws its cast from classic Sonic-franchise characters — for example Amy as a melee and ranged stunner and Tails as a ranged support who can fly teammates — with executioners being corrupted versions of the same characters. Forsaken features an all-star roster of Roblox community characters as both Survivors and Killers, each with unique abilities and cosmetics, and its roster is generally deeper and more ability-driven.
Both games are free to play on Roblox. Each has optional cosmetics and progression you earn by playing, and any paid extras are typically cosmetic rather than pay-to-win. You do not need to spend anything to play or to reach the escape objective in either game.
About This Comparison
This comparison covers Outcome Memories (place ID 14608970270, currently titled Outcome Memories v0.2) and Forsaken, two asymmetric survival horror games on Roblox, looking at concept, match format, characters, progression, and community as of July 2026. Outcome Memories is a Sonic.EXE-inspired indie project with 314 million-plus visits and around 7,876 concurrent players, while Forsaken is a polished, ability-rich game with a much larger community. Both are free, and both are actively updated, so stats and rosters change over time. For more, read our Outcome Memories guide and Outcome Memories hub, or dive into the Forsaken hub and Forsaken guide. You can also view Outcome Memories and Forsaken directly on Roblox.